News
From ER to ‘country doctors’
(by Maggie Fazeli Fard - February 06, 2008)
As
the region waits with bated breath on the fate of the former Pascack
Valley Hospital (PVH), two former PVH emergency room physicians have
embarked on a new medical venture: treating everything from sprained
ankles to food poisoning in the comfort of a patient’s home.
“We saw a need,” said Dr. John Hallenbeck, who along with Dr. Ken Cartaxo launched Urgent Care House Calls last Thursday.
The doctors, who have 35 years of ER experience between them, now make
house calls to treat minor emergencies that are too serious to be
handled in primary care doctors’ offices but that don’t warrant a trip
to – or a long wait in – the emergency room.
“The
reality of the matter is the other hospitals are not located in a
reasonable distance,” said Hallenbeck. “What’s a reasonable amount of
time to wait when your kid has a cut and is in pain?”
Hallenbeck and Cartaxo found themselves haunted by questions like this
as PVH stood on its last legs in 2007. In the weeks before the hospital
closed, the physicians began diverting patients to other hospitals.
“Just hearing people accept calls, they were inundated,” recalled
Cartaxo, who has worked in emergency rooms for 23 years and was at PVH
from 1988 to 2007. “The waiting times were unreasonable. The need was
there for these acute medical needs.”
Cartaxo met Hallenbeck about one year ago when the 12-year ER veteran
joined the PVH team after his former employer, Passaic Beth Israel,
closed. “We just seemed to click,” said Hallenbeck, who lives in
Montvale. “We both knew we wanted to do something. We just didn’t know
what.” They briefly considered opening an urgent care center, but it
didn’t take long before Cartaxo recalled a newspaper article about
house calls that he had read several years earlier.
The more the pair looked into starting the service, the more it seemed
like a viable option. “The majority of emergency room patients came in
with minor emergencies,” but they would sometimes have to wait several
hours before they could be seen, Cartaxo said, noting that serious
emergencies take precedence over minor ones like lacerations or flu
symptoms. PVH’s closing, he added, has aggravated the situation, as
more stress is put on the ERs of other area hospitals.
“If you cut your hand while making breakfast, do you want to spend the
whole day in the ER?” he asked. “We can decompress some of the
emergency rooms.”
In addition to lacerations, Cartaxo and Hallenbeck will treat simple
infections, sprains and vomiting, and can administer medications and IV
hydration. They will be on call 24 hours a day, seven days a week at
1-888-DRHC247, which they hope people will remember by memorizing
“1-888-DR House Call 24/7.” Blood work and x-rays are not currently
available, but the pair is confident that they will be able to offer
portable tests in the future.
Cartaxo also hopes to incorporate nutritional medicine. “I think the
pendulum is swinging back from high technology to more natural
treatments,” he said. His first call on Thursday, Jan. 31, involved
dispensing a vitamin cocktail through an IV.
“The country doctor,” Hallenbeck said, jokingly nodding towards his business partner.
Cartaxo agreed that people think that house calls are “a thing of the past.”
“It’s a losing proposition for primary care physicians,” Cartaxo said.
“We don’t have any office or staff. In private practice your biggest
expense is your staff. Our overhead is much less.”
The cost of a basic house call is $250; a follow-up costs $195.
Hallenbeck said that the cost of an evaluation by a physician in an
emergency room runs about $300, excluding hospital and treatment fees.
“The ER is the most expensive care being offered. The fees are steep.”
Hallenbeck added that while it’s cheaper than going to the emergency
room, the waiting times for doctor’s appointments can be two or three
days and the doctor’s practice is not always equipped to handle minor
emergencies. Doctors very often instruct patients, especially those who
call at odd hours, to go to the emergency room. “We’re basically going
to take people with minor emergencies that small doctor’s offices can’t
handle,” said Hallenbeck. “And it’s one-on-one while in the ER it could
be one-on-20.”
The doctors plan to work with local doctors, giving them an alternative
to sending people to the ER while giving detailed follow-up reports on
treatment provided during the house call. They also plan to contact
visiting nurses who care for homebound patients as well as local
hotels, where guests may be far from their home physicians and need
assistance with issues such as minor food poisoning.
They stress, however, that they are not aiming to take the place of
primary care physicians nor that of emergency room care. If anyone
calls them complaining of labor pains, chest pains, numbness or
uncontrollable bleeding, they will instruct the caller to hang up and
call 911.
Similarly, they have no qualms about calling paramedics if they arrive
on a scene and deem the situation needs emergency care. “A
non-life-threatening emergency could become life threatening,” admitted
Cartaxo.
In the end, the house call service boils down to two energetic doctors
with time on their hands and the desire to help their community. “I
enjoy seeing people and really helping them. Now that the ER is gone,
we can do it in a way that is satisfying to the patient and to us; to
provide care the way we’d want to be cared for.”
To contact Dr. John Hallenbeck or Dr. Ken Cartaxo at Urgent Care House Calls, call 1-888-DRHC-247 (1-888-374-2247).
Maggie Fazeli Fard's e-mail address is fazelifard@northjersey.com
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
February 27, 2008
DISPLACED ER DOCS DELIVER HIGH-QUALITY URGENT CARE TO NORTH JERSEY DOORSTEPS
Round-the-clock house-call practice serves communities left in the lurch by Pascack Valley Hospital closing
KINNELON, NJ –
Doctors Kenneth Cartaxo and John Hallenbeck, board-certified emergency room physicians, today announced the creation of Urgent Care House Calls, a unique practice providing convenience and personal service for minor medical emergencies in patients’ own homes.
Cartaxo, of Kinnelon, and Hallenbeck, of Montvale, practiced emergency medicine at Pascack Valley Hospital in Westwood until the facility was forced to close last November. With North Jersey residents faced with increased travel and extended wait-times in the ERs of surrounding hospitals, Cartaxo and Hallenbeck offer an attractive and cost-effective alternative to traditional emergency room care.
“The need for quality urgent medical care in Northern New Jersey is obvious and the closing of Pascack Valley and other area hospitals means the time is right to offer a new and different solution to area residents,” said Dr. Cartaxo a 19-year Pascack Valley ER veteran.
“To continue to care for this community without the burden of third-party payers and hospital bureaucracy is both an honor and a blessing. House-call medicine provides us with the opportunity to connect with patients in a way we rarely experienced in the emergency department because of time constraints,” he said.
With fees starting at $250 per visit, Cartaxo said Urgent Care Housecalls fees are a fraction of what the same service would cost in traditional hospital ER.
“Most minor emergencies can be cared for without the trappings and high cost of an ER. Patients get the prompt, professional treatment they need without the aggravation and exposure to communicable diseases present in overcrowded ER waiting rooms. We respond within the hour while the average wait-time for minor emergencies in the ER is nearly four hours.”
Urgent Care Housecalls physicians will visit area homes, offices and hotel rooms to provide personalized medical care They will treat adults and children with minor lacerations, sprains, minor infections of the throat, ears, lungs, urinary tract and skin, as well as vomiting, diarrhea and dehydration. Medications and IV fluids also can be provided at the time of the visit and many tests can be performed.
For more information about Urgent Care House Calls or to schedule an appointment, please call 1-888-374-2247 anytime of the day or night.
Sit back and dial a
doctor
Physicians bring urgent care from ER to LR (living
room)
Monday, April 21, 2008
BY ANGELA STEWART
Star-Ledger Staff
Reeling from abdominal pain one recent morning,
Diann Isola dreaded the thought of dragging herself
to the local hospital emergency room.
"You wait for hours and you never know what you are
going to catch in the waiting room," said the
45-year-old Kinnelon resident.
Isola decided to take another route.
Recalling an ad she'd seen in a community
newsletter, she dialed the number for an emergency
house call service. Within an hour, a doctor was
sitting in her living room.
"I called him at 10 o'clock and he was here by 11,"
she said. "He had a little black doctor's bag just
like one would expect."
The doctor, Kenneth Cartaxo, started Urgent Care
House Calls with another emergency room physician,
John Hallenbeck, in January. Both had worked at
Pascack Valley Hospital in Westwood until it closed
in November.
Cartaxo, 54, of Kinnelon, had been at the hospital
almost 19 years. Hallenbeck, 43, of Montvale, had
been there less than two years, although he worked
earlier in the emergency departments at St. Joseph's
in Paterson and the former Passaic Beth Israel.
"There is so much change going on in hospitals in
New Jersey," Hallenbeck said. "We have very little
job security."
Figuring the local emergency rooms would be
inundated after Pascack's closing, as well as that
of Barnert Hospital in Paterson, which was scheduled
to shut in three months, they came up with an idea
to offer personalized emergency care service in the
privacy of the patient's home.
Targeting problems ranging from cuts and sprains to
minor infections and viruses, Cartaxo and Hallenbeck
were hoping to appeal to people's desire to have
their emergency get priority status
"In the ER, I have 20 people waiting to come in and
I am rushing around trying to give everybody quality
care," Cartaxo said. "In this situation, there is
one patient and one doctor and I can focus."
While no one expects this kind of home-based urgent
care to replace emergency rooms, experts say what
these doctors are doing is actually a throwback to
how medical care used to be delivered.
"It's going back to an earlier era when, if you
could afford it, doctors came to you," said Fred
Hyde, a clinical professor at Columbia University's
Mailman School of Public Health. "You didn't go to
doctors."
CONVENIENT AND EFFICIENT
Patients pay a flat $250 fee for the house call, and
the doctor provides them with the necessary forms to
submit to their insurance company. Aside from home
visits, the pair will also go to hotel rooms,
businesses and even nursing homes.
"Most minor emergencies can be cared for without the
trappings and high cost of an ER," Cartaxo said.
They also carry an assortment of common antibiotics
and pain medications. Isola, who was suffering from
an inflammation around her intestines, was
prescribed two different antibiotics by Cartaxo and
paid wholesale price -- $18 for both -- for a 10-day
supply. Cartaxo also arranged for her to undergo a
CT scan at a local hospital, even obtaining
pre-authorization from her insurance company. She
walked right in and was seen.
On a follow-up visit a week later, Cartaxo
re-examined Isola and discussed her test findings.
That visit cost $195.
"I would definitely use them again," she said.
Retired police officer George DeGiovanni, 55, of
Park Ridge recently used the house call service for
a back problem.
"You get to the point where you bend or move the
wrong way and it goes out," he said.
His wife, Kerry, said there was no way she could
even have gotten her husband into the car because he
was in such pain. Hallenbeck arrived at their door
within a half hour of their call.
He gave DeGiovanni an injection of a pain
medication, as well as an oral muscle relaxant.
Hallenbeck also wrote a prescription for a pain
medication and called it into the pharmacy. He also
showed DeGiovanni some exercises he could do at
home.
"He has even called me twice now to see how I am
doing," DeGiovanni said.
The doctors carry malpractice insurance and the
joint policy for their house call service is
$20,000, which is a part-time rate.
And because they are still building the practice,
both have taken positions as emergency physicians --
Hallenbeck at Meadowlands Hospital and Cartaxo at
Newton Memorial.
They arrange their schedules so there is always 24-7
coverage for the house call service.
As business picks up, Cartaxo and Hallenbeck said
they hope to hire more doctors so they can treat
patients outside of Morris, Bergen and Passaic
counties, which is their primary coverage area.
John Sensakovic, associate dean of graduate medical
education at Seton Hall University in South Orange,
said as hospital emergency rooms become more crowded
and an increasing number of people use them for
primary care, urgent house calls could become more
popular.
"They may be on the cutting edge," he said.
-------------------------------------------
Daily Record
May 18, 2008 Page: COMMUNITIES22
Calling Dr. Cartaxo, calling
Dr. Hallenbeck
MICHAEL SCHOLL DAILY
RECORD
KINNELON -- The old-fashioned
doctor's house call is making a comeback in Morris
County, thanks to two veteran emergency room doctors
who have started a new business in which house calls
are their specialty.
Drs. Kenneth Cartaxo and John Hallenbeck,
board-certified emergency room physicians, started
Urgent Care House Calls at the end of January. It's
a unique practice providing convenience and personal
service for minor medical emergencies in patients'
own homes.
Cartaxo, a Kinnelon resident, said he and Hallenbeck,
of Montvale, worked as emergency room doctors at
Pascack Valley Hospital in Westwood until the
facility was forced to close in November because of
financial troubles.
The closure led to an increase in the emergency room
patient caseloads at other North Jersey hospitals,
with wait times of four hours or more becoming
commonplace for patients.
While Pascack Valley was in the process of closing
last year, Cartaxo and Hallenbeck realized that
people would benefit from an alternative to a
crowded emergency room. That alternative is the
old-fashioned house call, which offers an attractive
and cost-effective option for patients who want to
avoid the long wait and travel time associated with
emergency room visits.
Cartaxo said a house call is a viable alternative to
the emergency room for treatment of many of the
ailments that ER doctors commonly deal with. Many
patients who come to an ER have problems that are
not true emergencies, or do not need X-rays or other
expensive tests, he said. Visits to an ER also can
expose people to communicable diseases that may be
carried by other patients, he added.
Cartaxo and Hallenbeck will provide personalized
medical care for adults and children, they said.
Among the ailments the doctors can treat during a
house call are minor lacerations; sprains; and
infections of the throat, ears, lungs, urinary tract
and skin. They also treat patients suffering from
vomiting, diarrhea and dehydration.
The doctors carry many medications and IV fluids
with them, and also conduct a variety of tests with
the equipment they carry in their vehicles.
Although Cartaxo and Hallenbeck now work part of the
time at local emergency rooms, one of them is always
available 24 hours a day, seven days a week. They
respond to homes, offices and hotel rooms throughout
Morris, Bergen and Passaic counties, and generally
can arrive at a scene within an hour of receiving a
call at their toll-free number, (888) 374-2247.
The fee for an initial visit is $250, with follow-up
visits costing $195 each. There are additional
charges for suturing and the dispensation of
medication.
Payment up front
Cartaxo and Hallenbeck require payment up front for
their house calls and do not accept insurance,
although patients can apply on their own to their
insurance companies for reimbursement. The doctors
do accept credit cards through the use of a portable
credit-card reader that they can bring to patients'
homes.
Cartaxo said they do not accept insurance because
the administrative costs associated with processing
claims would be too burdensome. Without that burden,
the overhead costs for his and Hallenbeck's new
business are relatively low, with their major
expense being the cost of malpractice insurance.
The low overhead makes house calls economically
viable for the team, whereas other doctors are
burdened by the costs of operating an office and are
forced to see a high volume of patients to cover
those costs.
The need for high patient volume was what drove
house calls out of fashion years ago. Now Cartaxo
says the house call patients he has seen so far have
been "pleasantly surprised" by his willingness to
treat them in their homes.
He added that he likes house calls because they
allow him to give individual attention to each
patient and avoid the rush from patient to patient
that comes with a shift in the ER.
"You can take your time and really get to know
them," Cartaxo said. "It's very satisfying for the
doctor as well as the patient."
Michael Scholl may be reached at (973) 428-6644 or
mscholl@gannett.com.
Cartaxo and Hallenbeck require payment up front for
their house calls and do not accept insurance,
although patients can apply on their own for
reimbursement. The doctors do accept credit cards
through the use of a portable credit-card reader
that they can bring to patients' homes.
Help on Wheels
by Jessica Kitchin
Posted October 14, 2008
Two New Jersey doctors see the wave of the medical future in the past.
Dr. Cartaxo visits Kinnelon resident Mae Jacobs.
Dr. Cartaxo's car contains a plethora of medical equipment, including—IV pole
and fluid bags, suture and catheter kits, antibiotics, urinalysis and pregnancy
tests, stethoscope, credit-card machine, and other items that would puzzle a
passerby.
Photo by Colin Archer/Agency New Jersey.
One of these days, Dr. Kenneth Cartaxo is hoping to add a different type of
jumper cables to his car trunk. It’s crowded back there, but he should be able
to fit a portable heart defibrillator (which directs electrical energy to a
struggling heart) amid the IV pole and fluid bags, suture and catheter kits,
antibiotics, urinalysis and pregnancy tests, stethoscope, credit-card machine,
and other items that would puzzle a passerby.
Cartaxo’s job as a house-call doctor combines a nostalgic concept of the family
physician with a large dose of modern technology. (Fear not: Amid his collection
sits a familiar black leather bag, à la Marcus Welby.) The 54-year-old Kinnelon
resident joined with Dr. John Hallenbeck, 43, of Montvale, to start Urgent Care
House Calls (urgentcarehousecalls.net) in January, three months after Pascack
Valley Hospital in Westwood, where they were emergency-room doctors, closed.
In the months since, the two have been visiting patients, mostly in Bergen,
Morris, and Passaic counties. “It’s a nice way to practice medicine, and it’s
better for the patient,” Cartaxo says.
Take the case of Mae Jacobs. When Jacobs, 65, returned to her Kinnelon home
after a ski trip, she needed medical attention to deal with a rash on her face.
Dreading the idea of waiting in an ER or clinic, Jacobs called Urgent Care.
Within twenty minutes, Cartaxo was at her door. He diagnosed her with shingles,
a viral infection that had made its way into her cornea (and could have rendered
her blind).
He set her up with a prescription, immunity-boosting vitamins, and an
appointment with an ophthalmologist that day. She was quickly on her way to
recovery. “There’s no comparison,” she says of her experience. “You’re not
waiting for hours on end, you’re not dealing with a bureaucracy, and you’re able
to sit down and have a doctor focused on you.”
The doctors admit business is slow, and it may take time to break even after
their personal investments in equipment and malpractice insurance. Both work at
hospitals to supplement their incomes. But as ERs get more crowded, they hope
people will be inclined to call. “Ninety percent of the cases there aren’t true
emergencies,” Cartaxo says.
If a patient does call with an emergency, the doctors will instruct him or her
to call 9-1-1. But for sore throats, nausea, sprained ankles, even basic
physicals—patients can spend $250 and see a doctor within an hour without having
to get into a car. (A weekend and evening surcharge applies, and follow-up
visits are $195.) The doctors do not accept insurance, but provide the necessary
paperwork to file an insurance claim, which usually results in patients paying
only the copay.
Hallenbeck says his ER time gave him incredible experiences. “But you don’t have
the opportunity to spend a lot of time with patients, to get to know them.” As a
house-call doctor, that’s changed.
For Cartaxo, the personal nature of house calls reconnects him with his early
visions of medicine—and his days as a young EMT. “I’ve really come full circle.”
Link:http://njmonthly.com/articles/topdoctors/help-on-wheels.html?errors=socialweb_1
